GPSL Men’s Premier Final: Tartan Devils FC outlast Plum in penalty shootout thriller

In a grueling, emotional rubber match that pushed both sides through 120 minutes of intense summer heat, physical battles, and woodwork heartbreak, Tartan Devils FC once again proved why they are the gold standard of regional amateur soccer.

After battling to a dramatic 2-2 draw through regulation and extra time at F.N.B. Stadium, TDFC executed a flawless 3-0 performance in the penalty shootout to claim the 2026 Greater Pittsburgh Soccer League Premier Division Championship. The victory marks the Tartan Devils’ 10th league title in the last 12 years, continuing a remarkable dynastic run against a young, relentless Plum side seeking its first crown since 2009.

“Thankfully we have a bunch of guys who have been in big moments their whole lives, so this was just another one of those,” said TDFC player-coach Andy Kalas following the trophy presentation. “It was hot, it was tough, but we knew if we kept our composure when it went to penalties, our experience would carry us over the line.”

For Plum head coach Greg Pittman, whose squad featured a rejuvenated roster packed with young WPIAL talent, the result was a bittersweet testament to his team’s growth.

“I couldn’t be prouder of how our guys fought back today,” said Pittman.

“To go toe-to-toe with a team as decorated as Tartan Devils, bounce back from deficits twice, and take it to penalties shows the character of this group. It hurts to come up short, but Plum soccer is back on the map.”

Match Overview

First Half

TDFC controlled possession early, and had some chances around the 18. The boys in red had an amazing chance inside the box, but it shanked off the foot of the Plum keeper. 

Plum started to settle in, building momentum and winning some balls in the midfield. But the Tartans responded strong, scoring the first goal of the match with a low-struck ball inside the box. 

Plum responded just a few minutes later, with a strong shot from outside the box to equalize things at 1-1. 

The Tartans had another strong chance, but the Plum keeper made a leaping save to catch it with both hands.

TDFC scored again, getting numbers forward and delivering a shot from inside the box to pull ahead 2-1. 

The Tartans had another chance on a corner kick, but Plum swarmed the ball and defended successfully. 

Overall, the first half saw plenty of physicality and successful ball movement from both sides. Though Plum trailed, their keeper and backline stepped up to keep them in the game.

TDFC had another chance on a set piece, but the Plum keeper punched it up over the net. 

Second Half

Plum opened the second half with a strong shot, but the Tartan keeper caught it. Plum got set up with a penalty kick, which they scored to tie it up at 2-2.

The Tartans had a golden chance to pull ahead, but the shot went high over the net.

Both teams remained on the front foot, but no one could find the extra edge needed to score. 

The 2-2 draw remained throughout the second half, leading to extra time.

Extra Time

Plum had a fantastic opportunity inside the box, but TDFC was able to intercept and get the ball away. Both sides had by now made multiple substitutions, getting fresh legs in for the final two fifteen-minute periods.

TDFC responded with a good chance of their own, but the forceful shot bounced off the top bar. They had another strong cross into the box which set up a header, but the header bounced off the right post. TDFC fans were agonized by the back-to-back close chances.

In the second period of extra time, Plum had a long, arcing shot that bounced off the top bar. The match was getting closer to a thrilling conclusion, with both sides now having missed on close chances. There were physical battles at the midfield, tackles and headers getting more intense as the pressure mounted.

Extra time drew to a close, bringing on penalty kicks.

Penalties

Plum took the first PK. It was blocked by the TDFC keeper, who dove to the right post and punched it away.

TDFC scored on their first PK, a low-flying ball that sank into the back-left corner of the net.

The boys in purple took their next shot: it was also a miss, veering left and bouncing off the left post.

The Tartans were set to take their next PK. The shot was successful, hitting the back right corner.

Plum took their next kick. The ball bounced off the top bar, no good.

TDFC sank their third successful PK, drilling it into the top left corner. With that, the Tartans claimed another GPSL title, their 10th in 12 years. Plum, seeking their first in 17 years, came up short.

“We played through a lot of adversity today with the heat and the bounces hitting the post in extra time,” said TDFC’s Austin Rocke during his post-match interview.

“When you play in matches like this, you just have to stay mentally locked in. We trusted our keeper, trusted our shooters, and executed when it mattered most.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

View this post on Instagram

 

View this post on Instagram

 

 

Plum Roster

• Head Coach: Greg Pittman

Plum High School Alumni Core

• Garrett Chandler (Slippery Rock)

• Luke Gildea (Slippery Rock)

• Luke Kolankowski (Slippery Rock)

• Tyler Kolankowski

• Colin McKinley (Penn State Behrend)

• Benjamin Pittman (Pitt Greensburg)

• Lucas Pittman (Pitt Greensburg)

• Tristen Ralph (Pitt Johnstown)

Franklin Regional Core

• Blake Cooper (Penn State Behrend)

• Zach Lorenz (Sacred Heart)

• Jake Kimmich (Grove City)

• Luke Kimmich (Grove City)

• Matt Kimmich (Grove City)

   

WPIAL & Regional Standouts

• Sean Abraham (Riverview / Penn State Behrend)

• Nick Braun (Deer Lakes / Pitt Greensburg)

• Theo Campbell (Robinson Twp / Grove City)

• Nate Coleman (Kiski / Penn State Behrend)

• Ryan Higgs (Upper St. Clair / Grove City)

• Jarrod McDowell (Central Catholic / John Carroll)

• Ryan Merrick (Eden Christian / Grove City)

• Vincent Padalino (Cathedral Prep / Pitt Greensburg)

• Noah Gray (The Christian Academy / Grove City)

Tartan Devils FC Roster

• Head Coach / Player-Coach: Andy Kalas

Pro & Riverhounds Alumni

• Kevin Kerr (Former Riverhounds Midfielder & Hall of Famer)

• Robby Dambrot (Former Riverhounds Defender and current Pitt men’s soccer assistant coach)

• Nate Dragisich (West Allegheny / Duquesne / Former Riverhounds Midfielder)

• Neil Shaffer (Former Riverhounds and Harrisburg City Islanders Defender)

• Nick Kolarac (West Allegheny / Saint Francis / Steel City FC and Pro Veteran)

Veterans & Collegiate Standouts

• Matt Bischoff

• Zachary Bowers

• Johnathan Dragisich

• Winter Fondi (GK)

• Ramsey Hartley

• Reuben Jolo

• Manny Juarez

• Christian Lewandowski

• Greg Liebenguth

• Travis MacKenzie

• Keane McIvor

• Gabe Norris

• Sam Norris

• Owen Pearce

• Martin Pletz

• Austin Rocke

• Anthony Rowan

• Jack Shearer

• Cameron Territo